• Collecting debts - what not to do... Search for law notes: From today's Muncie Star-Press:BREAK-IN: A Muncie man was arrested Saturday afternoon, accused of dealing several thousand dollars worth of...
  • Blogging for business plans... Search for law notes: You want to start a business. You read everything you can about starting a business. You probably have read enough about needing a...
  • Starting a corporation... Search for law notes: The law require three things for starting a corporation:1. Corporate by-laws.2. Articles of Incorporation.3. An Employer Identification...
  • Best wishes to Marcia Oddi... Search for law notes: I have been remiss but Marcia Oddi of The Indiana Law Blog is ill. My best wishes go out to here. The Indiana Law Blog was the first...
  • Spatial Law and Policy Update (Augu... Search for law notes: PrivacyGoogle Street View in Germany - a non-issueSpain joins countries Probing Street ViewFacebook Location and PrivacyFacebook Enters...
  • Update on Spatial Law and Policy... Search for law notes: California has revised its proposed "Pay As You Drive" insurance regulations. A full copy of the regulations can be found here.Vector One...
  • Indiana Blog: Indiana Commercial Fo... Search for law notes: I ran across this blog in the past week and with more time I would have mentioned it earlier. The writer is John Waller from Indianapolis'...

Consumer news: Cemetery Problems

Cemetery ownership found themselves in the news this past week with headlines like Cemetery owners charged with fraud. What happened?
Robert Nelms, 39, and Debora Johnson-Nelms, 48, face multiple counts of theft, fraudulent or deceitful acts, violations of a cemetery perpetual care fund and using a perpetual care fund for prohibited loans. Nelms is president and chief executive officer of Memory Gardens Management Corp., which has Indiana locations in South Bend, Fort Wayne and Greenwood, where it owns Forest Lawn Memory Gardens.

In December 2004, according to court documents filed today in Marion Superior Court, the couple agreed to purchase the company for $27 million from owner Fred Meyer of Indianapolis. The Nelmses, who already had operated funeral homes in New Jersey and New York, arranged a bridge loan for the $13.5 million down payment, a probable cause affidavit says.

After the purchase, the loan was repaid using money from the company's trust fund, the affidavit says, even though that fund must be used to care for grave sites and cemetery grounds. That trust fund was transferred to a new bank, and all of the money in the account was withdrawn by April 2005, the affidavit says.
So far I have seen only one news story pointing out that these are cemetery funds and not pre-paid funeral trust funds. That story, Pirkle: Management problems don’t apply to local funeral home, came out of Washington, Indiana:

Michelle Brown with Gill Funeral Home said, “Nothing (misappropriated funds) has come from here because we’re not a cemetery. All (prepaid funeral arrangements) are bank trusts and are backed by a certified copy of death.”

The funeral home can’t access the money paid in to prepay for funerals until the bank is presented with a death certificate, according to Brown. Nelms, nor anyone else in the business, could access the money.

Since I advocated pre-paid funeral trusts as part of estate planning, emphasizing the difference between funeral trusts and perpetual cemetery funds is important for the public.

Indiana law describes with specificity how the cemetery is to set up and run a perpetual care fund.

That specific criminal penalties apply to misusing perpetual care funds does not clearly appear in the newspaper stories. The Indianapolis Star buried this paragraph towards the end of today's Cemetery case could spur other charges:

Keown, from the cemetery association, said the Nelms investigation prompted him to work with Indiana legislators to pass tougher penalties during the 2007 session. As a result, some of the charges against Nelms and Johnson were boosted from infractions to Class C felonies.

That statute reads as follows:

IC 23-14-48-9 Violation of chapter

Sec. 9. (a) Except as provided in subsections (b) and (c), a person who knowingly violates this chapter commits a Class A misdemeanor.

(b) A person who makes a false or fraudulent representation as to the existence, amount, investment, control, or condition of a perpetual care fund of a cemetery for the purpose of inducing another to purchase any burial right commits a Class C infraction.

(c) A person who knowingly or intentionally uses funds in a perpetual care fund or an endowment care fund established under this chapter for purposes other than the perpetual care of the cemetery for which the perpetual care fund or endowment fund was established commits a Class C felony.

Indiana does not list all its crimes in its criminal code and this serves as a reminder that bad business behavior may have criminal consequences.

0 comments:

Post a comment on: Consumer news: Cemetery Problems

Info recommended by: Law and Law blogger online Sponsored by: Law daily
  • The Cluetrain Manifesto... Search for law notes: I got to admit I have read bits and pieces and a lot about The Cluetrain Manifesto and I am still not sure how to put it all into effect...
  • Franchising - reading around... Search for law notes: Today, I found a new franchising resource: FranchiseBrief.com. I have not examined the site in any depth but it seems fairly sober in its...
  • Recent Spatial Law Links... Search for law notes: Privacy - in all it forms - continues to be a hot Spatial Law issue. An article in the Washington Post discusses how the Department of...
  • State v. Jay C. Fisher... Search for law notes: 08-14-07 A-3026-05T3Pursuant to N.J.S.A. 2C:11-5.1, a driver involved in amotor vehicle accident that results in the death of...
  • OECD Report published... Search for law notes: Earlier this months, the OECD published its communication outlook which presents the most recent comparable data on the performance of the...
  • Dying without a Will in Indiana ver... Search for law notes: I will take Indiana. This story from the Times of London, Wills injustice: fit for Dickens?, is worth reading if only to make us...
  • Follow up on powers of attorney and... Search for law notes: Just a few passing thoughts on the previous article Powers of Attorney - uses and problems and Times of London article I was commenting on...
  • Powers of Attorney - uses and probl... Search for law notes: I sum up a power of attorney as creating an alter ego for the person making the power of attorney. Let me throw in a couple of terms here....
  • Spatial Law and Policy Update (Augu... Search for law notes: Licensing/Intellectual Property rightsPirating of Sat Nav Maps in ChinaViacom to Appeal YouTube DecisionBing Adds OpenStreetMapDoes your...
  • Spatial Law and Policy Update (Augu... Search for law notes: PrivacyPrivacy pirates: Self-regulation is a sinking ship (IT World)Facial recognition App enables next-level web-stalking (Good...
  • Recent Developments in Spatial Law... Search for law notes: Rick Crowsey, of Crowsey Incorporated, forwarded me this article from the Washington Post on the increased use of GPS devices by law...
  • Commission comments on margin squee... Search for law notes: The European Commission has issued interesting comments to the Italian telecoms regulator Agcom over its proposed guidelines for ex-ante...